KPIs, OKRs, SMART goals: whatever you call them, they’re a fact of working life. And yet so often they’re set in January, forgotten by February and dusted off again the following January. By then it’s too late to change course, and you’ve missed the chance to celebrate the wins along the way.
The advice out there mostly boils down to this: a good KPI is measurable, but it should also be accessible, meaningful and achievable (as far as possible, anyway). There are a few key points to consider that could help to keep things live throughout the year.
Everyone should see the numbers
If your team can’t see the data behind a goal, they can’t do much to act on it. KPIs matter at every level of an organisation, so the numbers should be open to everyone.
There is of course a slight risk here. If we are not careful, shared data can reinforce any existing silos, “That £10k donation came from my direct mail, not your social media post” is a conversation nobody wants to be having. The fix is easy though: make the organisation’s aims trump team debates, and celebrate every win, whoever’s name is on it.
The right tools help too. When KPIs live in a spreadsheet on one person’s desktop, access will always be patchy. Reporting that pulls straight from your CRM and is open to everyone means everyone’s looking at the same numbers, from the same source, at the same time. No arguing about whose figures are right, and no waiting for the latest version (or version .3_FINAL2.xls).
Measure the hard stuff too
Not every KPI is financial, and not everything can be pulled from the CRM. Supporter engagement, loyalty and community support matter just as much. They’re harder to measure, but that’s no reason to skip them. Give some real thought to how you’ll track them consistently and fairly.
Make them mean something
Even the straightforward numbers need care. Finance teams will understandably want to maximise in-year net ROI, and at the extreme that’s easy: mail only the people most likely to respond and the results look fantastic. But the supporters you stopped contacting drift away, engagement drops, and long-term opportunities shrink. A colleague of ours called this the “ROI vortex” a few years ago, and it’s remarkably easy to get pulled in.
Good KPIs protect the long game, not just this year’s headline figure. That usually means balancing short-term results with measures of long-term supporter value.
For example, measuring a regular giving campaign purely on its initial return might encourage you to recruit supporters with the lowest acquisition cost. But adding measures such as 12-month retention, average gift value and longer-term supporter value gives you a much better picture of whether the campaign is actual going to deliver your needed 5 year ROI. We’ve seen CPAs in 2026 over £300 that had such high retention they will deliver more than similar activity that looks like half the cost.
Agree targets, don’t hand them down
A target that’s out of reach is demotivating, and one that’s too easy tells you nothing. If you haven’t tracked a measure before, you may not know whether a 1% or a 10% improvement is realistic, and that’s fine. Track it for a few months first, then agree the target.
And agree it with the team who’ll be accountable for it. People commit to goals they’ve helped shape.
Once agreed, targets need somewhere to live. A dedicated KPI results page in your reporting lets the team see progress at any point, not just at review time. That’s what turns a January target into something people can act on in April.
So, where do you start?
Good KPIs aren’t just about maximising income and checking in twice a year. They take the right measures, access to data, realistic targets and buy-in from the people responsible, plus a way to keep it all in view long after the planning session is over.
This is where we come in. We have worked with charities to define KPIs that balance short-term results with long-term supporter value, and to agree realistic targets with the teams who’ll deliver them. We can also build a bespoke KPI page in Canopy, our online reporting platform:
- Takes its data straight from your CRM, so there’s no manual number-crunching
- Is open to your whole organisation, so wins are visible to everyone
- Can email results to busy colleagues, so nobody’s left out of the picture
Having worked with Refuge to get their KPIs into Canopy for continual monitoring, Ian Campbell confirms
“Your most important objectives are only as meaningful as your ability to measure them – without KPIs, you can’t demonstrate whether, or to what extent, you’ve achieved what you set out to do.”
Fancy a chat about KPIs that work for your charity? Get in touch, and we'll help you keep them in sight all year round.
Author: Laura Leach, 2026 © Sequoia-Insights.com